Did you know that you can enjoy many members-only features simply by quickly registering (no CAPTCHA!)?
Registering gives you access to our giveaways, forum features, increased search performance, access to our Download Library, create your own blog & gallery, and more!
Once you have registered, stop by in 'Hello World', and introduce yourself.
Feature Comparison Elk M1 ISY994i-Newbie Question
Posted 31 July 2012 - 08:11 PM
the Elk m1 gold and the ISY994i seems to be a popular combination in home automation.. But I just watched a video on the Elk system, and it "seems" to do most of the things the ISY does ..... I can understand the Elks importance as the security part of the system, but I am a little confused on what value the ISY99 series adds that the Elk does not do.
I am having a new house built, and I need to ramp up quick in order to do any necessary wiring/prep. The house will be done in about 4 months. So I need to decide what I need fairly quickly
I am not looking at too exotic of a system... I just want to be able to dim lights in my home theater when I start a movie, With my Harmony one OR Harmony 900 remote,(which means I need an IR solution, I understand RF will not work even though the Harmony 900 is RF capable), turn my detached garage lights on from the house, or with my Iphone. maybe dim lights in a couple of other rooms.. and maybe eventually control irrigation and HVAC over my Iphone or the web.
Of course, I want all the security system advantages the Elk has, but the video says it also controls lights, HVAC, etc... so what does the ISY do then? Is the Elk not as robust?
Any info or links to documentation would be greatly appreciated.
Posted 01 August 2012 - 09:13 AM
The Elk does not have IR but the ISY has an IR option.
For simple control they are about the same.
If you are going to have multiple controllers, (i.e. a PC with a PLM) in addition to the Elk the links will become very difficult to program on your own such that device status stay in sync. The ISY will solve all those issues.
Edited by wuench, 01 August 2012 - 09:16 AM.
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users