IVB
Senior Member
A buddy of mine who doesn't currently do HA but is heavy into robotics, makers club, wants to dip his toe in.
His first goal is wireless doorbells ringing multiple speakers, but will then be moving onto a few other areas:
A) Water leak detectors and solenoid valve
B) Aquaponics monitoring and control (sensor reading, relay actuation)
C) Interface to nest (?)
He also sent me this message:
Analog sensors (ammonia level, dissolved oxygen, temperature) and some switches (flow switches level switched), digital outputs (can't think of any analog outputs needed) but it would be cool to pass values back from an ardiuno so the arduino does most of the control. This is less important as I could just do a wifi version of this.
He was initially looking into zWave potentially paired with SmartThings but I waved him off that as
[SIZE=12.8px]1) SmartThings = multi second lag time which is awful for a doorbell[/SIZE]
[SIZE=12.8px]2) zWave = not 100% reliable, which for Water leak/valve shutoff is bad[/SIZE]
[SIZE=12.8px]My experience in the high reliability space is with things that are overkill (ie Elk) but pre-built. I'll point him here, but does anyone have any ideas in the "cheaper even if he has to do more legwork" space?[/SIZE]
His first goal is wireless doorbells ringing multiple speakers, but will then be moving onto a few other areas:
A) Water leak detectors and solenoid valve
B) Aquaponics monitoring and control (sensor reading, relay actuation)
C) Interface to nest (?)
He also sent me this message:
Analog sensors (ammonia level, dissolved oxygen, temperature) and some switches (flow switches level switched), digital outputs (can't think of any analog outputs needed) but it would be cool to pass values back from an ardiuno so the arduino does most of the control. This is less important as I could just do a wifi version of this.
He was initially looking into zWave potentially paired with SmartThings but I waved him off that as
[SIZE=12.8px]1) SmartThings = multi second lag time which is awful for a doorbell[/SIZE]
[SIZE=12.8px]2) zWave = not 100% reliable, which for Water leak/valve shutoff is bad[/SIZE]
[SIZE=12.8px]My experience in the high reliability space is with things that are overkill (ie Elk) but pre-built. I'll point him here, but does anyone have any ideas in the "cheaper even if he has to do more legwork" space?[/SIZE]