Proficient Audio M4

royalj7

Active Member
Does anyone have any experience with Proficient's new distribution amps? I was researching the Russound CAA and came across this. Looks pretty nice, good power for these class of amps, and a good selection of keypads. I have not been able to get a good spec sheet on it (the website's one leaves much to be desired) nor do I know price or where to buy.

Thanks!
--Jamie
 
Jamie,

We're a Proficient dealer and install lots of their speakers, but I've not yet sold or installed any of their distributed audio units. I have seen and heard them and they appear to be well built.

Here's some links that you may or may not have already found... let me know if you have any questions and I'll try to answer them:

http://www.proficientaudio.com/manuals/M4QuickStartGuide.pdf
http://www.proficientaudio.com/Literature/M4DataSheet.pdf
http://www.proficientaudio.com/Literature/...icsBrochure.pdf

Cheers,
Paul
 
Hehe, thanks for taking the time to answer all these questions Paul. I had not seen the files you posted. I didn't know you were a Proficient dealer, or I would of asked these questions in the other thread!

The unit looks pretty darn good. Lots of keypad choices and priced comparatively to the CAA. Looking over the documentation it seems like over the CAA I would be getting: more power per zone, party mode which I think is pretty nice, and contact closure capability. The most glaring thing I lose with the M4 I think is 2 zones of course. I don't know if I can live with that, but maybe.

How do you see the unit stacking up to Russound and other multi-room amps?

--Jamie
 
Jamie, Have you looked at the Nuvo Grand Concerto? It is less expensive than an equivalent Russound and has very good sounding digital amps, plus a nice to buttonled OLED keypad.
 
Are the Grands out yet? I haven't actually seen them listed as available yet, nor any pricing information.
 
Steve said:
Jamie, Have you looked at the Nuvo Grand Concerto? It is less expensive than an equivalent Russound and has very good sounding digital amps, plus a nice to buttonled OLED keypad.
The Grand Concerto should be out soon, but I think it's beyond what Jamie wants to spend. He's looking at the Russound CAA66 which is more in line with the Nuvo Essentia.

The Grand Concerto is a competitor for the Russound CAV6.6...

I'm always keeping my eye on new stuff and like the looks of the Grand Concerto keypad, but I really don't like the feel of the membrane keys. Would be interested to hear what others who have touched it think?

Cheers,
Paul
 
royalj7 said:
Hehe, thanks for taking the time to answer all these questions Paul. I had not seen the files you posted. I didn't know you were a Proficient dealer, or I would of asked these questions in the other thread!

The unit looks pretty darn good. Lots of keypad choices and priced comparatively to the CAA. Looking over the documentation it seems like over the CAA I would be getting: more power per zone, party mode which I think is pretty nice, and contact closure capability. The most glaring thing I lose with the M4 I think is 2 zones of course. I don't know if I can live with that, but maybe.

How do you see the unit stacking up to Russound and other multi-room amps?

--Jamie
The Proficient M4 controller is sexy looking and well built, but I think the Russound keypads win hands down. They're much more handsome and since this is the interface it's what you will see and use day-to-day.

Proficient has optional transport & numeric keypads that you can add to the basic PMK keypad, but now it's a 3-gang keypad. Russound's CAA66 has the optional KPSC keypad that combines both transport & numeric features in a single keypad.

If you really need the transport buttons at each zone, you should probably be looking at the CAV6.6 anyway... by the time you add up the extra keypads you start to close in on the cost of the more capable CAV6.6 unit.

Proficient Audio also has the M6 which is 6-zone, 6-source with built-in tuners but last I knew, it wasn't shipping yet.

Right now I still prefer the Russound gear over the other competitors in this price range... customers really love the keypads and I've found the gear to be very reliable. Add to that the fact that Russound has been embraced by the HA industry integrating with Cinemar, HomeSeer, CQC, Elk, ect. and that's the reason it's my brand of choice right now for distributed audio...

Cheers,
Paul
 
Steve,

Do you work for Nuvo? You seem to push it a lot.

Your math must be different then mine but $3500 (for the Nuvo) is always, in any language or society, more expensive then $2000 (for the Russound CAV)


Nuvo is MUCH MORE expensive... Period.
 
I'm always keeping my eye on new stuff and like the looks of the Grand Concerto keypad, but I really don't like the feel of the membrane keys. Would be interested to hear what others who have touched it think?
Paul, If we are talking about the same thing, the Grand keypad is a glass capacitive touch, much like a touchscreen or some of the flat appliance control panels. It is not a membrane. Yes, it is different, it is like touching glass whereas the other keypads have a regular tactile push button.

Steve,

Do you work for Nuvo? You seem to push it a lot.

Your math must be different then mine but $3500 (for the Nuvo) is always, in any language or society, more expensive then $2000 (for the Russound CAV)


Nuvo is MUCH MORE expensive... Period.
No, if I worked for Nuvo my affiliation would be in my sig. I'm sorry if you feel mentioning it twice (in two different threads) is 'pushing' it. People need to choose what's right for them based on several factors and they come here looking for opinions and options. While I am human and sometime mix my facts up, I try very hard to give accurate and factual information as well as opinion. My personal opinion is that the Nuvo Grand is nicer than the equivalent Russound, whether that be a CAV, CAM or whatever. I spent a good amount of time at EHX looking at them both and talking to people that have seen, used and installed both. I heard from a few people that the Nuvo digital amps were better than the Russounds and in a side by side test actually sounded better. Would I tell people, or 'psuh' people based on this, of course not, but I *do* feel obligated to mention to them and have people make their own decision. All I can tell you is the Nuvo is my personal choice for most of the reasons mentioned above. Many people do not have the luxury of attending EHX and talking to some of the pros that use these systems. I also never said anything negative about the Russound stuff. It is quality eqiuipment as well and I always mention Compoint which is an attractive and sometimes needed option.

And lastly, yes, my math is different than yours. I would encorage you to check your math and state apples to apples facts. The only objective comparison is to compare at list/retail prices, not ebay or Joe's bargain basement. I am looking at Russound's 2006 Product Guide which is a catalog they hand out at the show. In it they list the 'Minimum Advertised Price'. To be fair, the CAV supports video as well so I don't know if thats the best model to compare to, but thats what you and Paul mentioned. The price listed in the guide for the Russound CAV6.6-S2 which is the amp, 6 UNO-S2 keypads and a remote is $3,999. The equivilaent list price of the Nuvo Grand with the amp, 6 OLED keypads and remote is $3,499. In the math training I've had, that makes the Russound unit $500 more than the Nuvo. So please, for the benefit of the membership here, please post facts. Heck, the retail price of the CAV alone without keypads is $2,199 which is more than the price you stated. Now sure you can argue you can get a better price somewhere but that is wildly variable and cannot be used for comparison. I personally would not buy this type of equipment from anyone but a known rebutable dealer with a warranty.

I wish you luck with whatever you choose and hope that everyone does their due diligence in choosing a system to meet their personal needs and wants.
 
I'm sorry but I just can't believe anybody is comparing these systems on cost because none of them appear to be a good deal to me. A 6 zone system at $3,500 is $583 per zone. And that does not include a media server. I assume this includes a tuner but if you add a media server that is able to display album and track data on the room keypads you have to add another $2,000 to that for a total of $916 per room!

By contrast I buy Philips MCD 708 micro systems for $200 at the local BJs and couple them with a $250 Squeezebox for a total of $450 per room. For that I get synchronized music in all zones via the Squeezebox player with full album/track/artist info (or Internet radio station info). I get 50 watts per channel in a super efficient Digital amp with local tuner and CD/DVD at each location. Local Knob volume control OR IR remote for all functions. Bright VFL displays that you can read from across the room instead of squinting at some LCD display. Display can show home automation messages in addition to music related stuff. And I don't have to agonize over my choice of "keypad location" if I decide to re-arrange the room because everything works from a single ethernet jack.... no custom holes in the walls! (For $50 more I could even eliminate this restriction and get the wireless version of the Squeezebox).

Considering the cost and limitations of these multi-room systems from NuVo and Russound, I just don't see the value in considering them at all, let alone worrying about how one compares to another!
 
upstatemike said:
Considering the cost and limitations of these multi-room systems from NuVo and Russound, I just don't see the value in considering them at all, let alone worrying about how one compares to another!
Tell us what you really think. :D

I tend to agree with you that the distributed systems are lacking and the keypad UI's are restrictive, especially when compared to a squeezebox. The value of a $220 squeezebox compared to russound keypads is shocking.

The tradeoff with your solution (and mine probably) is that I need to have a bunch of local 'stuff' in each room. As a minimum that 'stuff' would be a set of powered speakers sitting next to the squeeze box, at worst a reciever + speakers. Now my desk is cluttered compared to a keypad on the wall and speakers in the wall...

I'd buy a squeezebox with an AM/FM radio and an IPod dock for $350 in a second.

Chuck
 
Steve,

I had looked at the Nuvo Essentia, but thanks for mentioning it. As Paul mentioned, if I was looking at the Russound CAV or the Xantech MRC packages, the Nuvo Grand would be in the running, but my budget is a bit cheaper :D I think systems like the Xantech and Nuvo should be mentioned more often, because they offer some compelling solutions depending on ones needs/budget. That said, Russound is where I'm leaning ;)

Mike,

You have to remember those are the MRSP of the systems, the actual prices are lower. Plus most of those systems have video capability (composite) and there is only one piece of equipment to fail (as opposed to the multiple squeezeboxes I think your setup includes). Not saying they aren't expensive, that's why I'm looking at the "little cousins" of each, which put the price per zone around $200-250.

Paul,

Thanks for the feed back. I think the M4 would really of been a option if I didn't need atlest 5 zones, but I don't think I can make do with 4 and once we go up to the M6 it gets into the CAM/CAV area and out of mine. Have you installed any of the CAA systems or does most people go with the CAV?

Thanks,
--Jamie
 
Back
Top