upstatemike
Senior Member
Just found out HTD has some interesting new products coming out in January so I'm putting this decision on hold to see what the new stuff has to offer.
Monk said:Watching with interest - my aging Russounds draw 40 watts each - idle. Time to move on.
Monk said:Nice! I don't need that granularity. All zones play the same thing 99 % of the time. Homeseer & select alarm related announcements get played to all zones.
Mike, your play lists are through Amazon Music I'm guessing?
Work2Play said:I'm going through a little bit of this... I ended up going with the Monoprice one because my needs are minimal. That said, it's just a source switcher - it has no built in streaming capabilities.
My sources right now are all Amazon Echo Dots. I haven't gotten to the security aspect yet, but I plan to tie security through a mixer to the intercom override zone, as well as the doorbell (I plan to install a DoorBird doorbell when I can figure out how to get wire there!). That said, the house also has a couple security speakers already in place, so I'll have them working together. If the amp loses power, those speakers will still work.
I never liked the Russound/Commpoint solution for retrofit applications - it basically requires the speakers to loop through the intercom piece along with another Cat5 - it'd be difficult to retrofit. HTD is enticing as well, but doesn't have the same driver support.
TrojanHorse said:I have the monoprice amp. Not yet using the 12v trigger, but when I think about how I’d use it, I would also send the serial command to the amp to turn on the zones I want and make sure they have the right volume and aren’t muted for example. It feels to me like you’d also want to use the RS-232 protocol in addition to the 12v signal. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
upstatemike said:I am currently looking at the Rolls Ducking Module (DU30b) as a way to mix in announcements. Going to get one to test but at $80 apiece I don't know how practical it would be. Would need one per zone or one per input, depending on how I design the system.
I was planning to use the $400 HTD MC66 for my switching Matrix but at $450 the Monoprice unit is a better deal because it includes the keypads where HTD charges an additional $50 per keypad. So for $700 I get 6 zones of HTD with keypads while Monoprice will give me 12 zones with keypads for only $200 more.
Other Pros and Cons:
Monoprice has built in amps that I probably don't need. Will ignore except I wonder how much power they will use even if idle? Monoprice gives a 12V output per active zone which might be useful. Doesn't look like the Monoprice page override is much use but the "mute all" would be handy if it works on the line out and not just the speaker outputs.
HTD has both fixed and variable audio outputs which I can see me using but it only has a single 12V out when any zone is active. All inputs are RCA which is cleaner for me than converting to 3.5mm. HTD offers a network gateway while I will have to find one that works with Monoprice (Global Cache?)
Both have Homeseer plugins but the Monoprice one does not work with multi-unit master/slave configurations. I think the HTD plugin has some missing functions at this point (fairly new)
Two unanswered questions I have with Monoprice:
1- The Monoprice keypads connect via some kind of hub that is not pictured anywhere in the literature or manual,,, what exactly does this look like and is there any configuration to it?
2- When you connect 2 Monoprice units as Master/Slave, what exactly is shared beyond inputs? In other words what works differently in master/slave mode than would be the case if 2 units were kept separate and the audio sources just split via Y connectors to feed each unit?
upstatemike said:Two unanswered questions I have with Monoprice:
1- The Monoprice keypads connect via some kind of hub that is not pictured anywhere in the literature or manual,,, what exactly does this look like and is there any configuration to it?
2- When you connect 2 Monoprice units as Master/Slave, what exactly is shared beyond inputs? In other words what works differently in master/slave mode than would be the case if 2 units were kept separate and the audio sources just split via Y connectors to feed each unit?