Just getting into a new house here (got the keys on Friday the 13th, but won't be moving in until after the 21st) and going to setup the Elk M1 Gold with either Insteon or UPB.
But, need help/advice on the matter... If all goes well, my house may be used as a demo house for my work (well, the studio will be, until it's rented - mortgages in Southern California aren't cheap).
My original intention was to get the OmniPro II with UPB, however, after speaking with Steve and Dave? from Insteon at the recent NASBA Digital Home event, they convinced me to go with Elk... I still have to get back to them on organizing a training event a little closer to our area, but have other pressing matters...
Now, the question is:
UPB or Insteon?
I've been reading these forums for quite some time and read of the horror stories with Insteon... I've been playing around with UPB for well over a year now, and I know what it can/can't do.
But, my main concern (after functionality), is if it can accomplish some basic lighting controls in conjunction with the Elk M1 Gold.
I see that with UPB, I can setup links/scenes and whatnot, but it appears that with Insteon, I can only have 1 group - has that changed yet?
These questions apply to Insteon:
Can the group have lighting devices at various levels (i.e. a scene)?
Since I don't know about the Elk software releases (don't have a panel, can't register for the downloads), is there an update on the support of more than 1 group? Or is this limit an issue in programming the M1XSP (heard that PowerHome can be used to setup Insteon devices/groups within the M1XSP - does it allow setting up groups beyond "1"/device 193)? Is there a free alternative to the Powerhome product to program the M1XSP?
My overall goal would be the ability to initiate scenes (watch movie, etc...), but it appears that it can't be done through the Elk with Insteon at this time. I really don't want to have house controllers/keypadlincs or anything like that - just using the Elk keypad. However, if there is no side effect (i.e. Elk can still control lighting properly), then I wouldn't mind placing a couple controllers in strategic locations.
I don't really care about groups if I can have the Elk controller send various DIM commands out - is this possible at all with Insteon/UPB and the Elk? Can I, through a script, tell the Elk to set a light at a certain level/dim amount? If so, then I could care less about the scenes and just script everything (don't mind that - spend too much time scripting/coding anyway).
I have a self-imposed budget for this (can I afford it without getting yelled at), and will have to pass WAF...
The house specs:
2100 sqft (2 story)
34 total toggle switches (5 of with are paired to dimmers in a 3-way circuit, and 3 are in a 4-way circuit)
11 total dimmers
8 total lutron motion sensor light switches (in bathrooms)
In the end, I would like to replace as many (if not all) switches with either UPB or Insteon...
estimated cost of UPB switches at approximately $75/switch = $3975 (now that is definitely a bit excessive!)
estimated cost of Insteon switches at approximately $33/switch = $1749 (a little better!)
Budget-wish, Insteon is it because I don't really want to spend one month's house payment on UPB... I can get by with the Insteon price, but I want to make sure it can do everything I want it to, and not be a pain.
If anyone has an recommendations, please reply back - I am hoping to place a full order before this weekend.
Total equipment tally that's required:
ElkM1Gold (full system package)
M1XSP
M1XEP
M1XIN (qty unknown, need to tone/count runs)
M1DBHR (Retrofit because they ran 4-conductor home-runs to the keypad locations, instead of CAT5)
M1KP2 and/or M1KP (3 more in addition to unit included with system package)
----------------
Is there a way to hook up the Elk M1 Gold (or any other system for that matter) to a cell phone? We aren't getting any phone service, and would rather use a cell phone - which costs less than a landline! Even if it needs to hook up through a computer to the cell phone - no matter. I have a spare Blackberry 8700C - has USB, not sure if it's capable of being a "modem" or serial device, but I can probably find a different phone to use... I would just like to go through a cell phone instead of a landline... If it's not feasible, then I may need to get a VOIP account or something, but I would prefer to minimize monthly expenses.
But, need help/advice on the matter... If all goes well, my house may be used as a demo house for my work (well, the studio will be, until it's rented - mortgages in Southern California aren't cheap).
My original intention was to get the OmniPro II with UPB, however, after speaking with Steve and Dave? from Insteon at the recent NASBA Digital Home event, they convinced me to go with Elk... I still have to get back to them on organizing a training event a little closer to our area, but have other pressing matters...
Now, the question is:
UPB or Insteon?
I've been reading these forums for quite some time and read of the horror stories with Insteon... I've been playing around with UPB for well over a year now, and I know what it can/can't do.
But, my main concern (after functionality), is if it can accomplish some basic lighting controls in conjunction with the Elk M1 Gold.
I see that with UPB, I can setup links/scenes and whatnot, but it appears that with Insteon, I can only have 1 group - has that changed yet?
These questions apply to Insteon:
Can the group have lighting devices at various levels (i.e. a scene)?
Since I don't know about the Elk software releases (don't have a panel, can't register for the downloads), is there an update on the support of more than 1 group? Or is this limit an issue in programming the M1XSP (heard that PowerHome can be used to setup Insteon devices/groups within the M1XSP - does it allow setting up groups beyond "1"/device 193)? Is there a free alternative to the Powerhome product to program the M1XSP?
My overall goal would be the ability to initiate scenes (watch movie, etc...), but it appears that it can't be done through the Elk with Insteon at this time. I really don't want to have house controllers/keypadlincs or anything like that - just using the Elk keypad. However, if there is no side effect (i.e. Elk can still control lighting properly), then I wouldn't mind placing a couple controllers in strategic locations.
I don't really care about groups if I can have the Elk controller send various DIM commands out - is this possible at all with Insteon/UPB and the Elk? Can I, through a script, tell the Elk to set a light at a certain level/dim amount? If so, then I could care less about the scenes and just script everything (don't mind that - spend too much time scripting/coding anyway).
I have a self-imposed budget for this (can I afford it without getting yelled at), and will have to pass WAF...
The house specs:
2100 sqft (2 story)
34 total toggle switches (5 of with are paired to dimmers in a 3-way circuit, and 3 are in a 4-way circuit)
11 total dimmers
8 total lutron motion sensor light switches (in bathrooms)
In the end, I would like to replace as many (if not all) switches with either UPB or Insteon...
estimated cost of UPB switches at approximately $75/switch = $3975 (now that is definitely a bit excessive!)
estimated cost of Insteon switches at approximately $33/switch = $1749 (a little better!)
Budget-wish, Insteon is it because I don't really want to spend one month's house payment on UPB... I can get by with the Insteon price, but I want to make sure it can do everything I want it to, and not be a pain.
If anyone has an recommendations, please reply back - I am hoping to place a full order before this weekend.
Total equipment tally that's required:
ElkM1Gold (full system package)
M1XSP
M1XEP
M1XIN (qty unknown, need to tone/count runs)
M1DBHR (Retrofit because they ran 4-conductor home-runs to the keypad locations, instead of CAT5)
M1KP2 and/or M1KP (3 more in addition to unit included with system package)
----------------
Is there a way to hook up the Elk M1 Gold (or any other system for that matter) to a cell phone? We aren't getting any phone service, and would rather use a cell phone - which costs less than a landline! Even if it needs to hook up through a computer to the cell phone - no matter. I have a spare Blackberry 8700C - has USB, not sure if it's capable of being a "modem" or serial device, but I can probably find a different phone to use... I would just like to go through a cell phone instead of a landline... If it's not feasible, then I may need to get a VOIP account or something, but I would prefer to minimize monthly expenses.