18 months ago, I got fed up with x10 reliability and decided to try insteon. I bought 20 or so switches(combination of dimmers and relays). Was very impressed with the control reliability. So far, I've not had a single failure even with signals traveling 130 feet from one end of my house to the other and across legs.
However, I bought those switches with the understanding the other products like wireless remotes, motion sensors, etc would be avaiable soon. But that never came and there's no word from Smarthome when this will happen. I bought the software SDK so have spent some time in the insteon.net forum. Insteon released quarterly road map a year ago and missed almost every milestone. And when I say missed, I mean almost every product scheduled for release over the last year never came to be. That combined with people constantly complaining about bugs in the PLC and SDM and pretty much no help from smarthome on anything has left me and many others with the impression that development has been stalled. Additionally, reading here about so many of you having problems with failing springs in the switches is starting to make me regret the 20 switches I did buy. Also, SH raised the price of their ICON switches 50% from $20 to $30 and have proceeded to tell me twice when I asked that they've always been $30.
I held off buying the other 100+ switches and modules I'd need to complete my conversion because I wanted to be sure I'd get the supporting products (yet to be developed and released) before making that kind of investment.
Looking at Z-Wave, the product selection is far more impressive and covers pretty much everthing I need. Z-Wave is more expensive, but not much more.
So the big question: what would I be giving up to jump from insteon to Z-Wave? UPB is out of the question as it's well over twice as costly.
However, I bought those switches with the understanding the other products like wireless remotes, motion sensors, etc would be avaiable soon. But that never came and there's no word from Smarthome when this will happen. I bought the software SDK so have spent some time in the insteon.net forum. Insteon released quarterly road map a year ago and missed almost every milestone. And when I say missed, I mean almost every product scheduled for release over the last year never came to be. That combined with people constantly complaining about bugs in the PLC and SDM and pretty much no help from smarthome on anything has left me and many others with the impression that development has been stalled. Additionally, reading here about so many of you having problems with failing springs in the switches is starting to make me regret the 20 switches I did buy. Also, SH raised the price of their ICON switches 50% from $20 to $30 and have proceeded to tell me twice when I asked that they've always been $30.
I held off buying the other 100+ switches and modules I'd need to complete my conversion because I wanted to be sure I'd get the supporting products (yet to be developed and released) before making that kind of investment.
Looking at Z-Wave, the product selection is far more impressive and covers pretty much everthing I need. Z-Wave is more expensive, but not much more.
So the big question: what would I be giving up to jump from insteon to Z-Wave? UPB is out of the question as it's well over twice as costly.