It never said what was worng other than the partitions had been erased. On startup, it did give errors reading sector 0 of the drive in question.
What lead me towards an Acronis product, was, when using E's CD, the ONLY program that could access the HDD was Acronis Disk Editor.
I even went to Maxtor.com (the drive's manufacturer) and downladed their software and it didn't work. (it would encounter an error and restart).
What's funny, is everything I tried could SEE the HDD (drive0), but NONE of them could access it.
A neat thing about the Acronis Disk Director suite, is the bootable CD version has ALL the capabilites of the window's version. So I have since unistalled it from the PC I created the boot CD on and will just keep the CD handy to use on ANY PC that needs help.
The software can also create/resize partitions without losing data, so that could be a useful feature in the future.
Everything is working fine now. I even ran chkdsk (on reboot) and it reported 0 errors.